Shares of Palantir Technologies (NASDAQ:PLTR) fell nearly 7% in early Tuesday trading, significantly underperforming the broader market, as the S&P 500 slipped just 0.2% and the Nasdaq Composite dropped 1%. The selloff came after Citron Research, one of the most prominent short-sellers on Wall Street, released a scathing report on Palantir’s valuation.
Citron argued that Palantir’s stock is trading at levels far beyond rational comparison, especially when benchmarked against one of the world’s most valuable artificial intelligence companies, OpenAI. The report reignited long-standing concerns that Palantir, despite its AI narrative, is priced for perfection in a way that leaves little room for error.
Palantir Technologies Inc. is a data analytics and software company founded in 2003 by Peter Thiel, Alex Karp, Joe Lonsdale, Stephen Cohen, and Nathan Gettings with the mission of building platforms that enable organizations to integrate, analyze, and make sense of massive and complex datasets. Headquartered in Denver, Colorado, Palantir initially gained attention for its deep ties to U.S. government agencies, particularly in defense, intelligence, and national security, where its software was used for counterterrorism operations and intelligence gathering following the events of 9/11. Over the years, the company became synonymous with big data and advanced analytics, offering tools that helped agencies detect patterns, uncover hidden connections, and make critical real-time decisions.
The company’s flagship platforms, Palantir Gotham and Palantir Foundry, have defined its reputation in both government and commercial sectors. Gotham has been widely deployed across defense and intelligence communities, allowing analysts to connect disparate data sources into actionable insights. Foundry, on the other hand, has expanded Palantir’s footprint into the corporate world, giving industries such as healthcare, energy, finance, and manufacturing the ability to transform raw data into operational intelligence. These platforms are built around a philosophy of integrating siloed data into a unified operating system, empowering organizations to optimize performance, reduce inefficiencies, and respond to emerging risks.
Palantir’s growth has been fueled by its ability to secure long-term contracts with high-profile government agencies including the U.S. Department of Defense, the Department of Homeland Security, and international governments, which made up the bulk of its early revenue streams. More recently, the company has aggressively expanded into the private sector, striking deals with leading corporations and becoming a key player in the application of artificial intelligence to enterprise workflows. This dual positioning—government reliance and commercial expansion—has given Palantir a unique place in the technology ecosystem.
The company went public in 2020 through a direct listing on the New York Stock Exchange under the ticker symbol PLTR, marking one of the most high-profile debuts of that year. Its public listing highlighted both its ambitious growth trajectory and the controversies surrounding its business model, including debates over its reliance on government contracts, the ethical implications of its technology, and its sky-high valuation relative to revenue. Despite these debates, Palantir has successfully branded itself as an AI-driven data pioneer at the center of digital transformation efforts across industries.
Today, Palantir Technologies is viewed as both an innovator and a disruptor. It operates at the intersection of data science, artificial intelligence, and government policy, offering critical tools for decision-making in times of uncertainty. While celebrated by some as an indispensable partner for institutions navigating the complexities of the digital age, it is also scrutinized for the risks tied to its concentration of customers, regulatory challenges, and questions about scalability. Nonetheless, Palantir remains one of the most recognized names in the data analytics sector, shaping the narrative around how advanced software and AI can be harnessed to solve the world’s most pressing problems.
Citron Calls Palantir’s Valuation “Irrational”
Citron’s bearish case rests on a simple yet striking comparison. OpenAI, which recently confirmed it was raising $6 billion at a $500 billion valuation, trades at an implied price-to-sales (P/S) multiple of about 17x. Even this, Citron notes, represents “the highest multiple of any scaled SaaS stock in the world,” and is extreme by traditional valuation standards.
By contrast, Palantir is trading at a P/S ratio 7.5 times higher than OpenAI’s implied multiple. Applied directly, this would place Palantir’s fair value closer to $40 per share, a staggering drop from its current trading level of $162 per share. Citron concluded that even under generous assumptions, Palantir remains deeply overvalued, and that today’s market pricing cannot be justified by the company’s fundamentals.
CHECK THIS OUT: How Globalstar (GSAT)’s Strategic Apple Partnership is Changing the Satellite Game and Intel (INTC)’s Epic Comeback: Why Wall Street May Be Dead Wrong About This “Dying” Chip Giant.
Palantir vs. OpenAI: Growth and Scale Misalignment
The comparison to OpenAI cuts particularly deep because of the scale and transformative potential of OpenAI’s technology. OpenAI is widely viewed as the company leading the generative AI revolution, reshaping entire industries from search to productivity software to enterprise automation. Its growth trajectory and ability to command massive investment flows far outpace Palantir’s relatively narrow footprint in government and enterprise contracts.
Yet paradoxically, Palantir’s stock trades at a substantially richer valuation than OpenAI would if it were public. This imbalance suggests that much of Palantir’s pricing is driven more by speculative enthusiasm and retail-driven hype than by realistic growth expectations.
The Profitability Argument and Its Limits
To be fair, Palantir bulls point to one major distinction: Palantir is profitable, while OpenAI remains unprofitable and continues to burn cash at a breakneck pace. This profitability has allowed Palantir to pitch itself as a sustainable long-term AI play, in contrast to many startups still searching for a viable business model.
But as Citron and other skeptics emphasize, the valuation gap remains far too wide to ignore. Profitability alone does not justify trading at a multiple 7.5 times greater than the most highly valued AI startup in the world. For Palantir to earn its current price tag, it would need to deliver breakneck growth and expanding margins for many consecutive years, a level of execution that borders on impossible in a competitive landscape filled with giants like Microsoft, Amazon, and Google.
A Stock Priced for Perfection
The bearish thesis ultimately boils down to one point: Palantir is priced for absolute perfection. Investors are assuming that the company will not only sustain but accelerate growth, expand into entirely new markets, and defend its moat against much larger competitors. This kind of flawless execution is rare in the technology industry, and history shows that companies trading at such lofty valuations are often punished harshly when growth slows even modestly.
At current prices, Palantir leaves investors with little margin of safety. Even minor disappointments in contract growth, international expansion, or AI adoption rates could trigger steep corrections.
Broader Market Risks Amplify the Downside
The timing of this bearish call is also significant. The broader market is experiencing turbulence amid inflation concerns and tightening monetary policy. High-multiple growth stocks, particularly those riding the AI hype cycle, are among the most vulnerable to valuation resets. Palantir, with its stretched multiples and retail-heavy investor base, could face disproportionate downside in such an environment.
Investor Beware: Citron’s Warning Resurfaces Old Concerns
This is not the first time Palantir has been accused of being wildly overvalued. Since its public debut, the stock has been a lightning rod for debate between true believers and skeptics. Citron’s report has revived these arguments, giving voice to concerns that have long simmered beneath the surface: that Palantir is more hype than substance, more meme-stock than sustainable blue-chip.
For retail investors, the risk is heightened by the emotional attachment many have developed toward the company’s AI story. As with previous speculative bubbles, sentiment-driven enthusiasm can evaporate quickly, leaving latecomers with heavy losses.
Conclusion: Why the Bear Case on Palantir Is Growing Stronger
Palantir Technologies has positioned itself as a pioneer in applied artificial intelligence, with real-world government and enterprise contracts and a narrative that appeals strongly to investors seeking exposure to the AI revolution. But the numbers tell a more sobering story. With a valuation multiple more than seven times higher than OpenAI’s implied sales ratio, and with expectations that demand nearly flawless execution for years to come, Palantir represents one of the most overstretched stocks in today’s market.
While its profitability is a positive, it is not enough to justify today’s lofty prices. For investors, the risk-reward balance looks increasingly unfavorable. Unless Palantir can somehow accelerate growth to levels rivaling the largest players in the AI industry, the bearish case—that this stock has far more room to fall than to rise—remains compelling.
READ ALSO: POET Technologies (POET) Delivers 1.6T Optical Innovation—Is a Massive Revenue Surge Next? and BigBear.ai (BBAI) is Flying Under the Radar—But Not for Long. Here’s Why Bulls Are Piling In.
